Should you Save or Kill Nightsong in Baldur's Gate

In the vast world of Baldur's Gate, players are faced with numerous choices that shape the outcome of their journey. One of these pivotal choices revolves around Nightsong, a mysterious character whose fate lies in the hands of the player. Should you save Nightsong, or should you choose to end their life? In this blog post, we will explore the consequences of both decisions and help you make an informed choice.

Opting to kill Nightsong carries a series of significant repercussions. Firstly, Shadowheart, one of your companions, will undergo a noticeable alignment shift towards Shar, the Mistress of the Night. This shift may alter her behavior and choices throughout the game, potentially leading to unforeseen consequences.

Furthermore, numerous non-playable characters (NPCs) will meet their demise if Nightsong is eliminated. This loss of potential allies and questlines might have a lasting impact on the overall narrative of your playthrough.

Additionally, choosing to kill Nightsong means forfeiting the opportunity to uncover their true identity. Nightsong's past and motivations remain shrouded in mystery, and eliminating them will leave many questions unanswered.

Lastly, killing Nightsong makes it more challenging to deepen your romantic relationship with Shadowheart. Her connection to Nightsong and the events surrounding their fate play a significant role in her character development and potential romance arc.

On the other hand, saving Nightsong presents a range of enticing benefits. By sparing their life, players are rewarded with the revelation of Nightsong's true identity as a deva, a celestial being of great power. This revelation opens up new possibilities and storylines that can greatly enhance your Baldur's Gate experience.

Moreover, saving Nightsong grants you access to powerful artifacts: the Moonlight Glaive and Selune's Spear of Night. These weapons possess extraordinary abilities and can greatly aid you in your battles against the forces of evil.

By choosing to spare Nightsong, no NPCs will meet their demise. This ensures that potential allies and questlines remain available for exploration, enriching your gameplay experience.

Additionally, the deva's assistance in the final boss fight against Ketheric Thorm cannot be underestimated. Nightsong's celestial powers can turn the tides of battle in your favor, making the encounter more manageable and potentially leading to a more satisfying outcome.

Furthermore, saving Nightsong may influence Shadowheart's path, potentially causing her to revert to a cleric of Seluna. This change in her beliefs and alignment can alter her interactions with you and other characters, offering new narrative possibilities.

Lastly, sparing Nightsong facilitates the further development of your romantic relationship with Shadowheart. By saving Nightsong, you deepen the bond between the two characters, potentially leading to more intimate and meaningful moments throughout the game.

To save Nightsong, players must pass a challenging DC 21 Charisma check. This check requires a persuasive approach and a deep understanding of the motivations and values of the characters involved. It is crucial to carefully consider your dialogue choices and utilize any relevant information you have gathered throughout your playthrough.