Should You Lie to Goddard in Lies of P Overture

By Daniel Hidalgo | 2025-06-15 11:44:33
Discover the intriguing choices in  Lies of P Overture: Should You Lie to Goddard.  Explore the moral dilemmas and captivating narrative that challenge your decisions.
In Lies of P Overture, the highly acclaimed timed lie mechanic from the base game makes its anticipated return, presenting players with new moral dilemmas. This system, which intricately ties into P's burgeoning humanity, was a cornerstone of the original narrative. Early in the Overture expansion, players will encounter Goddard, the Blind Painter, and face a significant choice. This guide will explore that decision and answer the simple question: should you lie to Goddard the Blind Painter in Lies of P Overture?

Lies of P Overture: Should You Lie to Goddard

Lies of P Overture continues the tradition of meaningful choices, with the lie mechanic remaining central to its narrative. Given the game's inspiration from Pinocchio, the theme of lying and its implications for humanity is unsurprising. In this particular instance, P must decide how to respond to an artist who has lost their vision.If you've played the base game, you're aware that lying significantly impacts P's humanity level, as the narrative consistently emphasizes that only humans are capable of deceit. Many of the lies P can tell in the base game provoke reflection on why humans lie—whether it's to spare feelings, prevent escalation, or for other complex reasons. The situation with Goddard perfectly aligns with this theme.

Should You Lie to Goddard?

The decision to lie to Goddard primarily hinges on whether you are aiming to increase P's humanity level, as this is the only real difference between the two available options.

  • If your goal is to increase P's humanity, then the answer is a resounding yes, you should absolutely lie to Goddard the Blind Painter. Doing so will grant a boost to P's humanity level.
  • To lie to Goddard, you must select the following option:"Incredible! It is a brilliant work of art."

Lying in this manner is one of the most effective ways to boost P's humanity in Overture, alongside other key choices such as saluting Veronique during Chapter 2.

Consequences of Telling the Truth:If you choose to tell Goddard the truth (i.e., that her work isn't incredible or brilliant), you will not get a second chance to lie. She will become very upset and ask you to leave. Furthermore, if you return later in the game, she will no longer be in her chair, effectively locking you out of any further interactions or potential humanity gains from her.

Where to Find Goddard the Blind Painter in Lies of P Overture

While most players will likely spot Goddard, it is possible to inadvertently miss her if you rush through the early sections of Overture.

You will find Goddard at the very end of Chapter 1, just before you board the tram headed for Eventide Hotel Krat. She is visible sitting in a wheelchair from the Zoo Tram Station Stargazer. Simply look to the left of the entrance to the tram, and you will see Goddard.



Platform(s): PlayStation 4 PS4, PlayStation 5 PS5, Windows PC, MacOS, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Genre(s): Soulslike
Developer(s): Round 8 Studio
Publisher(s): Neowiz
Engine: Unreal Engine 4
Release date: September 19, 2023
Mode: Single-player
Age rating (PEGI): 18+
Video preview



Other Articles Related

How to beat the Parade Master in Lies of P
Struggling with the Parade Master in Lies of P? Learn the best strategies, weaknesses, and tips to defeat this challenging boss and progress in the game!
How to beat Lumacchio, Leader of the Bastards in Lies of P Overture
Master the art of defeating Lumacchio, the Leader of the Bastards, in Lies of P Overture with our expert tips and strategies.
Should You Lie to Goddard in Lies of P Overture
Discover the intriguing choices in  Lies of P Overture: Should You Lie to Goddard.  Explore the moral dilemmas 
How to beat Two-faced Overseer in Lies of P Overture
Master the Lies of P Overture with our guide on defeating the Two-faced Overseer. Unlock strategies and tips for victory!
How to Beat Tyrannical Predator in Lies of P Overture
Master the art of defeating the Tyrannical Predator in Lies of P Overture with our expert tips and strategies.
How to Solve Corroded Cipher Machine in Lies of P Overture
Unravel the mysteries of  Lies of P Overture  as you solve the Corroded Cipher Machine. Dive into a thrilling adventure
How to Solve the Bloody Cipher Machine in Lies of P Overture
Unravel the mystery in  Lies of P Overture  as you solve the Bloody Cipher Machine. Dive into a thrilling adventure
How to beat Premetamorphic Green Hunter in Lies of P Overture
Master the art of defeating the Premetamorphic Green Hunter in Lies of P Overture with our expert tips and strategies. 
How to get Black Rabbit Brotherhood outfit in Lies of P Overture
Discover how to obtain the Black Rabbit Brotherhood outfit in Lies of P Overture with our step-by-step guide. 
How to Find All Blue Checkmarks in Deltarune
Discover the ultimate guide on how to find all blue checkmarks in Deltarune. Unlock secrets and enhance your gameplay today!
How to Win the Poker Game in Hitman (The Banker DLC)
the art of poker in Hitman’s Banker DLC with our expert tips and strategies to secure your victory. Play smart and win big!
Should You Salute Veronique in Lies of P Overture
Discover the intriguing world of  Lies of P Overture  and explore whether you should salute Veronique. Uncover secrets and insights  
How to Reach the Antidote in Time in Hitman
Discover essential tips and strategies on how to reach the antidote in time in Hitman. 
How to Cure Status Ailments in Bravely Default Flying Fairy HD
 Discover how to cure status ailments in Bravely Default Flying Fairy HD. Master your gameplay and enhance your adventure