Should You Give Benny to Katsumi in Bloodlines 2

The journey of Phyre, the self-named Elder Vampire and The Nomad, begins in the tense, politically charged underbelly of Seattle's Kindred society. Your very first major political decision in Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2 (VTMB2) revolves around the troublesome figure of Benny Muldoon, the disgraced Sheriff of the Camarilla court.Benny holds a key to understanding the mysterious mark on Phyre’s hand, making his capture paramount. However, his fate is complicated by the fact that two powerful factions want him: Prince Ryong and the ruling Camarilla, and Katsumi, the leader of the Thin-Blood Anarchs.The choice of who receives Benny marks your first alignment with Seattle’s vampiric politics. While the main story remains largely consistent, your decision immediately shapes your early relationships and reputation.

Bloodlines 2: Should You Give Benny to Katsumi

The Setup: Benny and the Black Mark

Benny Muldoon is a problem for everyone. His misconduct as Sheriffhas made him a target, and his disappearance leaves a vacuum in thelocal Camarilla structure. For Phyre, capturing him is a necessary stepto gain the favor of Prince Ryong, allowing the Elder Vampire to remainin Seattle and pursue answers about their own condition.

Theplayer is forced to decide: honor the Prince's mandate and return Bennyto the Camarilla, or give him to the Anarchs, a group fighting forfreedom from the rigid hierarchy.

Option 1: Handing Benny Muldoon to Katsumi and the Anarchs

Choosing to give Benny to Katsumi is a decisive nod toward the anti-establishment faction in Seattle.

Immediate Consequences with the Anarchs

• Relationship Status: This choice instantly establishes an amicable relationship with the Anarchs.
• Katsumi's Response: Katsumi, the Anarch leader, is grateful for Phyre's cooperation and explicitly invites Phyre to the Anarch den, the Hole in the Wall.
• Benny’s Fate: Benny is taken into custody by the Anarch gang and is removed from the rest of the narrative.

Consequences with the Camarilla

• Ryong's Reaction: Upon returning to Weaver Tower, Prince Ryong expresses clear disappointment that Phyre failed to bring her Sheriff back. Your standing with theCamarilla, particularly Ryong, will not be favorable initially.
• Immediate Benefits: Despite Ryong's displeasure, she allows Phyre to stay in Seattle, acknowledging the need for the Elder's presence.
• The Masquerade Pass: Importantly, the breach of the Masquerade that put Phyre in this situation is allowed to slide for the time being.
• The Sheriff Role: With Benny gone, Ryong requires a replacement. She grants Phyre Benny's vacant position as Sheriff, effectively unlocking the rest of the main Bloodlines 2 story regardless of the failure to deliver him.

Summary: This path opens doors with the Anarchs early on but strains relationswith the Prince. The ultimate plot progression (staying in Seattle andbecoming Sheriff) remains the same.

Option 2: Handing Benny Muldoon to Prince Ryong and the Camarilla

Choosing to return Benny to Prince Ryong aligns Phyre with the establishedvampire hierarchy and builds immediate political capital with the ruling faction.

Immediate Consequences with the Camarilla

• Relationship Status: This choice builds a better reputation with Prince Ryong and the larger Camarilla society. They are clearlypleased that the matter was handled according to their wishes.
• Ryong's Response: Ryong is satisfied with Phyre’s competence and confirms that Benny will be punished according to Camarilla law, effectively removing him from the story.
• The Sheriff Role: As before, Benny's position is vacant, and Ryong appoints Phyre to the role of Sheriff, ensuring the story continues.

Consequences with the Anarchs

• Katsumi's Reaction: While Katsumi is disappointed and definitely less friendly toward Phyre, she does not launch an immediate attack or scorn the Elder entirely.
• The Invitation: Katsumi still extends an invitation to the Hole in the Wall in case Phyre ever decides to explore the Anarch faction later.

Summary: This path garners favor with the Camarilla and the Prince, ensuringsmoother initial interactions with the ruling class. The Anarchs remain a viable path, despite the initial disapproval. The ultimate plotprogression remains identical.

The True Impact: A Focus on Reputation Over Plot

Ultimately, the choice between giving Benny Muldoon to Ryong or Katsumi does not create a significant divergence in the long-term narrative of Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2. Regardless of who takes custody of Benny:

• Phyre gets to stay in Seattle.
• Phyre is appointed as the new Sheriff.
• Benny Muldoon is removed from the picture.

The decision primarily serves to establish Phyre’s initial reputation within the city. One side will appreciate the action, leading tofriendlier initial dialogue and a better first impression, while theother side will express disappointment. Over the course of the game,this initial choice is largely absorbed into the broader politicallandscape, making it more of a moral and role-playing decision than amajor branching point.

Which faction will you choose to impress with your first political maneuver in Seattle?

---

Other Articles Related

How to Perform the Crooked Trick in Skate
the crooked trick with our step-by-step guide. Learn essentialtechniques and tips to enhance your skateboarding skills 
How Do You Really Feel About Your Father? in Dispatch
Explore the complex emotions surrounding fatherhood in our insightfuldispatch. Discover how your feelings shape your relationship with yourfather.
How to Get New Abilities in Bloodlines 2
Unleash your character's full potential in Bloodlines 2. guide on acquiring new abilities and elevate your gaming experience
How to Get All Outfits in Bloodlines 2
Explore the moral dilemma in Bloodlines 2: Should you give Benny toKatsumi? Discover the implications of your choice 
Should You Give Benny to Katsumi in Bloodlines 2
Explore the moral dilemma in Bloodlines 2: Should you give Benny toKatsumi? Discover the implications of your choice  
How to Change Appearance in Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2
how to change your character's appearance in Bloodlines 2. Unlock customization options and enhance your gameplay 
How To Tranquilize And Move Dinosaurs in Jurassic World Evolution 3
Learn safe & effective dinosaur tranquilization & transport methodsin Jurassic World Evolution. Master darting, herd management &enclosure moves for a thriving park.
How To Increase Dinosaur Appeal in Jurassic World Evolution 3
strategies to enhance dinosaur appeal in Jurassic World Evolution 3.Learn how to attract visitors and create a thriving prehistoric park.
Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2: Which Clan Should You Choose
the perfect clan for your journey in Bloodlines 2. Exploreunique abilities, strengths, and lore to make an informed choice
Where to Find The Bronze Pocket Watch in Escape From Duckov
Searching for the Bronze Pocket Watch in Escape From Duckov? Find its exactlocation and a step-by-step guide to complete this key quest and unlockthe next part of the story.
Nefer Ascension and Talent Materials in Genshin Impact
essential Nefer Ascension and Talent Materials for Genshin Impact.Enhance your gameplay with our guides
How To Build Manekin In Genshin Impact
Learn how to build Manekin in Genshin Impact effectively. Our detailedguide offers essential tips and strategies 
How to Complete 'Klefki's Lost Key' Mission in Pokemon Legends Z-A
Dive into the 'Klefki's Lost Key' mission in Pokemon Legends Z-A.Explore detailed guides and expert tips to help you 
How to Complete 'Finding a Place For Heliolisk' Mission for Pokemon Legends: Z-A
Dive into Pokémon Legends Z-A and find out how to locate Heliolisk. Getinsights on its abilities, habitats, and tips for gameplay.
How to Get XL Gogoat in Pokemon Legends Z-A
Unlock the secrets to catching XL Gogoat in Pokemon Legends Z-A. Ourdetailed guide essential tips to help you on your journey