How To Solve The St. Katherine's Church Lead in Atomfall

The St. Katherine’s Church lead in Atomfall is one of the game’s most intricate side quests, offering multiple resolutions, hidden rewards, and moral dilemmas. Players must investigate the murder of Maisie Higgins, navigate political tensions between villagers and the Protocol, and decide the fate of those involved.This guide will walk you through every step—from discovering the crime scene to maximizing your rewards—while exploring the consequences of each choice.

How to Start the St. Katherine’s Church Lead

Locating the Crime Scene

St. Katherine’s Church is situated in Wyndham Village at coordinates 33.0 E, 78.8 N. Upon entering, you’ll witness Vicar McHenry and Pamela Shaw standing over Maisie Higgins’ corpse.

Initial Dialogue & Clues

• Vicar McHenry urges you to keep the murder quiet, fearing Protocol intervention.
• Neither the vicar nor Pamela provides useful information, but examining Maisie’s body reveals a Bloodied Note.
• The note indicates Maisie was investigating someone near Mereview Hotel from a nearby cottage.

This is your only lead—time to investigate.

Investigating Maisie’s Murder

Finding the Cottage Near Mereview Hotel

• The Mereview Hotel is in northwest Wyndham Village, but the key location is a condemned cottage at 31.4 E, 82.1 N.
• Entering the cottage counts as trespassing, so proceed cautiously.

Discovering the "Recent Movements" Note

Inside, you’ll find a note written by Vicar McHenry, instructing Maisie to monitor suspicious individuals. Her handwritten additions describe:

• An unidentified man heading past the hotel, over a stream, and into a rat-infested cellar.
• The note misleadingly says the man went right, but the correct path is left—crawl under a fence, cross the stream, then ascend stone steps to an abandoned building.

Exploring the Brewery Cellar

• Behind the building, blue cellar doors lead to the Brewery Cellar, swarming with poisonous rats.
• Use a melee weapon to clear them out.
• Grab the Molotov Cocktail crafting recipe from the wall.
• Crawl through a hidden hole behind the recipe to find a boarded-up room.

Hidden Loot & Additional Evidence

• Behind the boards is a B.A.R.D. Crate containing a Training Stimulant.
• A second note, "Captain Sims Doesn’t Suspect a Thing," further implicates Morris, the village shopkeeper.

Solving the Murder: Confronting the Culprit

With evidence pointing to Morris, return to Wyndham Village to confront him at the Village Shop. However, Vicar McHenry’s involvement complicates matters—he was extorting villagers and using Maisie as a spy.

Possible Resolutions & Rewards

1. Kill Morris

• Outcome: Morris dies; Vicar McHenry rewards you with an Atomic Battery (used to access locked areas).
• Consequence: Permanently removes Morris from the game.

2. Banish Morris from the Village

• Outcome: Morris leaves after protest. Vicar McHenry still rewards you.
• Unknown: It’s unclear if Morris reappears elsewhere.

3. Bargain with Morris (Best Reward)

• Outcome: Morris gives you the Crafting Manual (unlocks new skills) and reveals Mother Jago’s location (an important NPC in Casterfell Woods).
• Consequence: Vicar McHenry refuses further interaction.

4. Report the Murder to Captain Sims (Protocol Route)

• Outcome:
  • Soldiers occupy the church; Vicar McHenry becomes hostile.
  • Reporting Morris gets him arrested, and his shop is seized.
• Reward: Gains Captain Sims’ trust, crucial for accessing Skethermoor Prison.
• Downside: Lose access to the Vicar’s Key and Crafting Manual.

Optimal Strategy: Maximizing Rewards

For players seeking all possible benefits, follow this sequence:

Bargain with Morris first to obtain the Crafting Manual and Mother Jago’s location.

Return to Vicar McHenry—if you want the Atomic Battery, kill him and loot his key.

Report the murder to Captain Sims afterward to gain his trust without sacrificing previous rewards.

This morally questionable path ensures:

• Crafting upgrades
• Access to restricted areas (via Atomic Battery)
• Progress in Protocol storyline

Final Thoughts: Moral Choices & Consequences

The St. Katherine’s Church lead is more than a simple whodunit—it’s a web of deceit, power struggles, and player agency. Each decision impacts Wyndham Village’s fate, your standing with factions, and available rewards.

Will you:

• Side with the corrupt vicar?
• Spare Morris for personal gain?
• Align with the authoritarian Protocol?

The choice is yours—but choose wisely.

---

Other Articles Related

Where to Find the Dam Storeroom Key in Atomfall
Unlock the secrets of Atomfall! Discover how to find the Dam Storeroom Key and enhance gaming
How To Get a Torch in Atomfall
Discover how to obtain a torch in Atomfall with our comprehensive guide.
Where To Find The Sewer Tunnel Key in Atomfall
Unlock the mystery in Atomfall! Discover how to find the Sewer Tunnel Key
How To Get The Platform Gate Key in Atomfall
Unlock the secrets of Atomfall! Discover how to obtain the Platform Gate Key
Site Office Key Location in Atomfall
Discover the Site Office Key location in Atomfall. Unlock secrets and enhance your gameplay
Where To Find Druid Castle Key in Atomfall
Discover the location of the Druid Castle Key in Atomfall with our comprehensive guide.
How To Get Greenhouse Hut Key in Atomfall
Unlock the secrets of Atomfall with our guide on acquiring theGreenhouse Hut Key.
How to unlock the Protocol Documents Chest in Atomfall
Unlock the secrets of the Protocol Documents Chest in Atomfall. Findexpert tips and strategies
How to fix Atomfall audio bug
Fix the Atomfall audio bug with our expert tips and solutions. Get backto enjoying your game
Where to find all comic books in Atomfall
Unleash your inner comic book enthusiast with Atomfall. Find every comic book you seek
Skethermoor Location in Atomfall
Discover the Skethermoor location in Atomfall, a hidden gem filled with adventure and exploration.
How to Find Cat Island in Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Discover how to locate Cat Island in Assassin’s Creed Shadows with our step-by-step guide.
How to Report to Nobutsuna Sensei in Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Learn how to effectively report to Nobutsuna Sensei in Assassin’s Creed Shadows with our step-by-step guide.
How to Unlock Secret Level Laser Hell in Split Fiction
Unlock the secret level  Laser Hell  in Split Fiction with our step-by-step guide.
How To Find Dr. Garrow in Atomfall
Discover how to locate Dr. Garrow in Atomfall with our comprehensive guide.