Should You Punch or Shoot Oddman in Borderlands 4

In the chaotic world of Borderlands 4, side missions often deliver the franchise's signature blend of dark humor and moral ambiguity. Few choices embody this spirit more than the climactic decision in the "Exit Through the Rift Shop" quest, where players must decide the fate of the deranged scientist, Francis Oddman. This isn't just a simple good vs. evil pick; your decision has tangible gameplay consequences, including potential access to a secret trophy.
This guide will provide a comprehensive analysis of both options, helping you decide whether to punch Francis Oddman or shoot him for good.

The Story Behind the Oddman Dilemma

Before you can make an informed choice, it's crucial to understand who Francis Oddman is and what he's done. As you discover through ECHO logs and mission dialogue, Oddman wasn't just a quirky inventor. He was a scientist formerly employed by the mysterious Order, and he used his position to perform horrific experiments on the unsuspecting citizens of Kairos.
His goal? To find a mythical "paradise" by teleporting people through unstable rifts over and over again. The grim irony is that his discovered paradise is a nightmarish realm ruled by sentient lizard overlords. His reckless actions directly jeopardized countless lives, leaving you, the Vault Hunter, to deliver final judgment.

Consequence 1: Choosing to Punch Francis Oddman

If you opt for a non-lethal (but still violent) approach, you'll deck Oddman right in the jaw.

• Immediate Outcome: The force of your punch sends Oddman stumbling backward through an active rift portal. He vanishes into the dimensional stream, his ultimate fate unknown.
• Long-Term Implications: This is the critical choice for completionists. Punching Oddman is directly tied to the secret trophy/achievement "Rift Incompatible." This challenge requires you to eventually find Oddman's final resting place somewhere in the Borderlands 4 universe. By punching him into the rift, you keep his story alive, suggesting that future DLC or hidden areas will reveal what became of him. This choice leaves the door open for more content and lore.

Consequence 2: Choosing to Shoot Francis Oddman

For players who believe his crimes warrant a more permanent solution, the game offers a definitive alternative.

• Immediate Outcome: You draw your weapon and put a bullet in Francis Oddman. He slumps tothe ground, dead on the spot, and never enters the rift. His reign ofexperimentation ends right there in the Order Silo.
• Long-Term Implications: This choice offers immediate, cathartic justice and permanently closesthe book on his character. However, it may potentially lock you out ofthe "Rift Incompatible" trophy until you replay the mission, as his body remains in Deep Seven and cannot be found elsewhere.

Verdict: Which Choice Should You Make?

So, what is the best choice?

• For Trophy/Achievement Hunters: The clear answer is to Punch Francis Oddman. This is currently the only known way to progress toward unlocking the"Rift Incompatible" secret trophy. It ensures you are eligible todiscover his fate later in the game.
• For Role-Players Seeking Justice: If you're driven by narrative and your character's moral code, thechoice is harder. Shooting him delivers instant, permanent justice forhis victims. Punching him, while satisfying, could be seen as anincomplete solution, banishing him to a unknown dimension where he might continue his odd experiments.

Ultimately, while shooting Oddman might feel morally justified, punching him is the strategically superior choice for players who want to experience everything Borderlands 4 has tooffer without missing a hidden objective. You can always replay themission on another character to see the other outcome!

What did you choose to do with Oddman? Share your verdict with the community in the comments below

---

Other Articles Related

How to Get the Ghostbusters Gun in Borderlands 4
Unleash the power of the paranormal! Our guide details exactly how to get theproton pack-inspired Ecto-Phaser, the ultimate Ghostbusters gun, inBorderlands 4.
How to Fix Borderlands 4 One Fell Swoop Quest Bug
Stuck on the One Fell Swoop quest in Borderlands 4? Follow our quick, step-by-step guide to fix the common bug and complete the mission for good.
How to Open Order Bunkers in Borderlands 4
Unlock the secrets of Pandora and beyond! Learn how to open OrderBunkers in Borderlands 4 to claim exclusive loot, face new challenges,and uncover hidden Vault Hunter lore. Your guide to access and rewardsawaits.
How to Customize Vehicles in Borderlands 4
Master vehicle customization in Borderlands 4! This guide covers weaponupgrades, cosmetic skins, and performance mods to dominate the openworld in your ultimate ride.
How to Get to Ultimate Vault Hunter Level 5 in Borderlands 4
Level up fast with our guide on how to reach UVHM 5 in Borderlands 4. Getexpert tips on the best XP farms, optimal gear, and strategies toconquer the new endgame.
How to Beat All Vault Monsters in Borderlands 4
Defeat every Vault Monster in Borderlands 4 with our expertstrategies. Learn boss weaknesses, optimal gear, and phase-by-phasetactics to claim your legendary loot.
Where to Use Eridium in Borderlands 4
Unlock the potential of Eridium in Borderlands 4. Our guide reveals all thebest ways to spend this valuable currency, from powerful weapon upgrades to exclusive cosmetic items.
All Elemental Weaknesses in Borderlands 4
Master every encounter in Borderlands 4 with our complete guide to allelemental weaknesses. Learn which elements to use against armor,shields, and flesh for maximum damage. Dominate Pandora and beyond!
Should You Punch or Shoot Oddman in Borderlands 4
Engage in the ultimate moral and strategic dilemma: should you punch or shootOddman in Borderlands 4? We break down the hilarious consequences,hidden rewards, and which choice best suits your Vault Hunter'splaystyle.
Should You Destroy the Mind Swirl Machine in Borderlands 4
Facing the Mind Swirl Machine in Borderlands 4? This guide breaks down thecritical consequences of your choice: destroy it for a moral victory orpreserve it for power. Choose your side and reap the rewards.
How to Change MyCareer Difficulty in NBA 2K26
Level up your MyCareer with our guide on changing difficulty in NBA 2K26.Maximize your VC earnings and find the perfect challenge to dominate the court.
How to Solve the Waterstop Evocarium in Borderlands 4
Master the WaterstopEvocarium puzzle in Borderlands 4. Learn the solution to bypass theenvironmental challenges, unlock the secret chamber, and earn thepowerful unique reward.
How to Escape the No-Escape Room in Borderlands 4
Escape the inescapable! Learn the secrets, strategies, and step-by-step guideto beating the infamous No-Escape Room in Borderlands 4 and claim yourlegendary loot.
How to Solve the Bell Puzzle in Mob Rules in Borderlands 4
Master the Bell Puzzle in Mob Rules with our step-by-step guide. Learn thecorrect sequence to ring the bells and claim your legendary loot rewardin Borderlands 4.